Does my family member have schizophrenia or not?

Its ahrd to know if its schizophrenia or not.

why oh why are you pushing this , from reading your original post you said A was working. ok he has some odd behaviour but what single situation has led you to say ‘i cant handle this I need to get him to a psychiatrist’. has their being a violent outburst , can he no longer look after himself. my point is that schiz means in the vast vast majority of cases that a person can no longer function , they can not work , they can not concentrate , they can not go out.

producing a book on ‘surviving schizophrenia’ when there is no diagnosis in the first place , no gross dysfunction., is going to be contentious

why are you so afraid that you want to get A to a psychiatrist. the truth is if schiz happens you will know about it very quickly.

how old is A & B.

You need to get a diagnosis from a doctor. Free medical advice from strangers on the Internet is worth about half as much as you paid for it.

10-96

I’m confused about your last post Meteor. It seems that you’re making some incorrect and over-broad assumptions. How am I “pushing this”? I would much prefer A to go to a psychologist, it’s pretty clear he needs some mental help.

How would having the book “Surviving Schizophrenia” around be a bad idea? B was only around, not A. Though, considering that B became unreasonably agitated and violent, I now better realize that B has some mental issues as well. I’d recommend the book to anyone and everyone as it is one of the best books on mental illness that I have read. If you work with people, this book is indispensable. I’d recommend this book, especially, to people posting on these forums.

A is in his 50’s and B is in his 20’s. If anyone has more advice, please let me know.

You can try this link to get an answer NIMH » Publications About Brain Anatomy and Physiology

You are looking for advice fair enough , but being honest , if I had no diagnosis , I was working , functioning to a decent level , possibly knowing very little about mental illness , and if someone produced a book ‘surviving schizophrenia’ and left it lying around and expecting me to ‘learn’ from it , i gotta say it would cause an argument, schizophrenia is a serious illness possibly the worst of the mental illnesses. You simply do not have the know how to make these kinds of judgements.